trace_synthesis/summary/404.json
yuyr a84d51a101 1. 增加r1生成综合策略代码和输出;
2. 增加tasks;
3. 增加analysis部分,对策略进行归纳分类,然后进行评测。
2025-04-17 17:40:15 +08:00

82 lines
19 KiB
JSON
Raw Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters

This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.

{
"task_intent": "Upvote the newest post in books subreddit",
"prompt": "# Instruction\n- You are an expert in cleaning process data descriptions. Given a task, you are provided with a set of annotation description\ndata for a certain visual LLM related to human user operation videos. Plus, You are provided with full trace of playwright action,\nwhic includes action and url before and after the action.\n- You need to analyze all the descriptive data and ultimately summarize a complete and reasonable user operation description that can accomplish the given task.\n- For each strategy, give a clear list of the low level action sequence.\n\n# Task\nUpvote the newest post in books subreddit\n\n# Annotation description\n### Step-by-Step Actions in the Video Segment\n\n#### 1. **Initial State**\n- **Action:** The video begins with the webpage already open on the `/f/books` forum of a site that resembles Reddit but is labeled as \"Postmill.\"\n- **Page Changes:** The page displays a list of submissions under the `/f/books` forum, with titles, submission details, and comment counts visible.\n- **Possible Purpose:** The initial state sets the context for interacting with book-related content on this forum.\n\n#### 2. **Scrolling Down the Page**\n- **Action:** I scroll down the webpage.\n- **Page Changes:** As I scroll, more submissions under the `/f/books` forum come into view. The previously visible submissions move upwards and out of sight, replaced by new ones further down the list.\n- **Possible Purpose:** The purpose of scrolling is to view additional content that is not initially visible on the screen, allowing for exploration of more submissions within the forum.\n\n#### 3. **Hovering Over a Submission**\n- **Action:** I hover over a specific submission titled \"The letters of T. S. Eliot to Emily Hale that were kept sealed from 1956 to 2020 have been released for free online.\"\n- **Page Changes:** Hovering over the submission highlights it slightly, making it stand out from the other submissions. No other significant changes occur on the page.\n- **Possible Purpose:** Hovering over the submission likely serves to focus attention on it, possibly in preparation for clicking or to read the title and details more closely.\n\n#### 4. **Clicking on a Submission**\n- **Action:** I click on the submission titled \"The letters of T. S. Eliot to Emily Hale that were kept sealed from 1956 to 2020 have been released for free online.\"\n- **Page Changes:** After clicking, the page transitions to a detailed view of the selected submission. The new page shows the full content of the submission, including the original post, any images or links included, and a comment section where users can discuss the topic.\n- **Possible Purpose:** The action of clicking on the submission is intended to access more detailed information about the topic, engage with the content, and potentially participate in the discussion by reading comments or adding my own.\n\n### Summary\nIn this video segment, I begin by viewing the `/f/books` forum on the Postmill website. I then scroll down to see more submissions, hover over a specific submission to focus on it, and finally click on that submission to view its detailed content and associated comments. Each action is performed to explore and engage with the content available in the forum.\n\n# Playwright action\n[\n {\n \"action_uid\": \"link_Forums\",\n \"idx\": 0,\n \"action_repr\": \"frame.clickget_by_role(\\\"link\\\", name=\\\"Forums\\\")\",\n \"before\": {\n \"url\": \"http://ec2-3-133-227-75.us-east-2.compute.amazonaws.com:9999/\"\n },\n \"after\": {\n \"url\": \"http://ec2-3-133-227-75.us-east-2.compute.amazonaws.com:9999/\"\n }\n },\n {\n \"action_uid\": \"link_Alphabetical\",\n \"idx\": 1,\n \"action_repr\": \"frame.clickget_by_role(\\\"link\\\", name=\\\"Alphabetical\\\")\",\n \"before\": {\n \"url\": \"http://ec2-3-133-227-75.us-east-2.compute.amazonaws.com:9999/forums\"\n },\n \"after\": {\n \"url\": \"http://ec2-3-133-227-75.us-east-2.compute.amazonaws.com:9999/forums\"\n }\n },\n {\n \"action_uid\": \"link_books\",\n \"idx\": 2,\n \"action_repr\": \"frame.clickget_by_role(\\\"link\\\", name=\\\"books\\\")\",\n \"before\": {\n \"url\": \"http://ec2-3-133-227-75.us-east-2.compute.amazonaws.com:9999/forums/all\"\n },\n \"after\": {\n \"url\": \"http://ec2-3-133-227-75.us-east-2.compute.amazonaws.com:9999/forums/all\"\n }\n },\n {\n \"action_uid\": \"label_Sort by: Hot\",\n \"idx\": 3,\n \"action_repr\": \"frame.clickget_by_label(\\\"Sort by: Hot\\\")\",\n \"before\": {\n \"url\": \"http://ec2-3-133-227-75.us-east-2.compute.amazonaws.com:9999/f/books\"\n },\n \"after\": {\n \"url\": \"http://ec2-3-133-227-75.us-east-2.compute.amazonaws.com:9999/f/books\"\n }\n },\n {\n \"action_uid\": \"link_New\",\n \"idx\": 4,\n \"action_repr\": \"frame.clickget_by_role(\\\"link\\\", name=\\\"New\\\", exact=True)\",\n \"before\": {\n \"url\": \"http://ec2-3-133-227-75.us-east-2.compute.amazonaws.com:9999/f/books/new\"\n },\n \"after\": {\n \"url\": \"http://ec2-3-133-227-75.us-east-2.compute.amazonaws.com:9999/f/books/new\"\n }\n },\n {\n \"action_uid\": \"action_5\",\n \"idx\": 5,\n \"action_repr\": \"frame.clicklocator(\\\"article\\\").filter(has_text=\\\"Adults reading to each other out loud? Submitted by BitterStatus9 t3_1281s7t 6 m\\\").get_by_title(\\\"Upvote\\\")\",\n \"before\": {\n \"url\": \"http://ec2-3-133-227-75.us-east-2.compute.amazonaws.com:9999/f/books/new\"\n },\n \"after\": {\n \"url\": \"http://ec2-3-133-227-75.us-east-2.compute.amazonaws.com:9999/f/books/new\"\n }\n }\n]\n\n# Output format\n- 先总结整个任务的Objective然后按照Strategy-SubStrategy-action三级层次来给出整个过程\n- 接着给出整个操作流程后的观察和有趣的发现最后严格按照json格式输出三级层次的过程描述。\n- 最后的输出json应该是包在```{json}```之间最底层动作需要包含描述、对应的playwright动作指令顺序编号以及具体指令内容。\n\n# Example\n### Complete User Operation Description to Display Labeled Issues in kkroening/ffmpeg-python\n\n**Objective:** Filter and display all issues labeled as \"question\" in the kkroening/ffmpeg-python repository.\n\n---\n\n#### **Strategy 1: Navigate to the Repository**\n**Low-Level Action Sequence:**\n1. **Search for the user \"kkroening\"**\n - Click the global search bar (placeholder: \"Search GitLab\").\n - Type \"kkroening\" and press `Enter`.\n2. **Select the user from results**\n - Click the \"Users\" tab in search results.\n - Click on \"Karl Kroening @kkroening\" in the user list.\n3. **Access the repository**\n - Navigate to the \"Personal projects\" section.\n - Click on the \"ffmpeg-python\" project.\n\n---\n\n#### **Strategy 2: Filter Issues by Label**\n**Low-Level Action Sequence:**\n1. **Open the Issues tab**\n - Scroll to the left sidebar menu.\n - Click the \"Issues\" tab (displaying the count, e.g., \"Issues 402\").\n2. **Apply label filtering**\n - Click the search/filter bar in the issues list.\n - Select the \"Label\" dropdown from the filter options.\n - Type or select \"question\" from the label dropdown.\n - Click the search/apply button to confirm the filter.\n\n---\n\n#### **Final Oberservation**\nThe issues list will refresh to show only issues with the \"question\" label. The URL will reflect the filter:\n`.../ffmpeg-python/-/issues/?label_name[]=question`.\n\n---\n\n### Key Observations from Playwright Trace\n- The final URL after filtering:\n `http://ec2-3-135-39-80.../ffmpeg-python/-/issues/?label_name%5B%5D=question`\n confirms the \"question\" label filter is applied.\n- Critical interactions include selecting the \"Label\" dropdown and explicitly choosing \"question\" to refine results.\n\n### Final output\n```json\n[{\n \"strategy\" : \"Navigate to the Repository\",\n \"substrategies\": [\n {\n \"substrategy\": \"Search for the user \\\"kkroening\\\"\",\n \"actions\" : [\n {\n \"description\": \"Click the global search bar (placeholder: \\\"Search GitLab\\\"). \",\n \"playwright_idx\" : 18,\n \"playwright_instruction\" : \"frame.pressget_by_placeholder(\\\"Search GitLab\\\")Enter\"\n }\n ]\n },\n {\n \"substrategy\": \"Select the user from results\",\n \"actions\" : [\n ]\n }\n ]\n},\n{\n \"strategy\" : \"Filter Issues by Label\",\n \"substrategies\" : [\n ]\n}]\n```",
"response": "<think>\nOkay, let's tackle this problem. The task is to upvote the newest post in the books subreddit, but in this case, it's a site called Postmill. The user provided annotation descriptions and a Playwright action trace. I need to combine both to create a structured strategy with sub-strategies and actions, each linked to the Playwright steps.\n\nFirst, looking at the annotation description, the initial state is already on the /f/books forum. Then they scroll, hover, click a specific post. But the Playwright actions show a different sequence: clicking Forums, then Alphabetical, then books, changing the sort to New, and finally upvoting a post.\n\nWait, there's a discrepancy here. The annotation mentions starting on /f/books, but the Playwright trace starts from the homepage, navigates to Forums, then Alphabetical, then books, then changes the sort by to New. The actual upvote action is in action_5. So the annotation might be from a different part of the process, but the Playwright trace is the actual steps taken. The task is to upvote the newest post, so the correct steps would involve sorting by New first, then upvoting the top post.\n\nSo the key steps from Playwright are:\n\n1. Click \"Forums\" link (action_uid: link_Forums, idx 0)\n2. Click \"Alphabetical\" (idx1)\n3. Click \"books\" (idx2)\n4. Change sort from Hot to New (click the \"Sort by: Hot\" label, then select \"New\" (idx3 and idx4)\n5. Looking at the Playwright actions, after idx3 (clicking the \"Sort by: Hot\" label), then idx4 is clicking the \"New\" link. Then, on the /f/books/new page, action_5 is clicking the upvote button on a specific post.\n\nSo the correct sequence is navigating to the forums, selecting books, sorting by New, then upvoting the first (newest) post. The annotation's description of scrolling and hovering might not be necessary if the Playwright trace shows a more direct approach. But maybe the annotation is from a different part, like after navigating to the post, but the actual upvote is done from the list view? Wait, in the Playwright action_5, the action is clicking the upvote button on an article in the list, not entering the post's page. Because the URL remains the same after upvoting. So the upvote is done directly from the list view, not by entering the post.\n\nSo the strategy should be:\n\n1. Navigate to the Books forum.\n2. Sort posts by New.\n3. Upvote the first (newest) post in the list.\n\nNow, mapping each step to the Playwright actions:\n\n- Navigate to Books forum: actions 0,1,2 (Forums -> Alphabetical -> books)\n- Sort by New: actions 3 and 4? Wait, action 3 is clicking the \"Sort by: Hot\" label, then action 4 is clicking \"New\". So changing the sort order from Hot to New.\n- Then action 5 is the upvote.\n\nSo the Playwright steps are:\n\n0. Click Forums (from homepage to forums)\n1. Click Alphabetical (probably to list forums alphabetically)\n2. Click books (navigate to /f/books)\n3. Click the \"Sort by: Hot\" dropdown (opens the sorting options)\n4. Click \"New\" to sort by New (navigates to /f/books/new)\n5. Click the upvote button on the first post.\n\nSo the strategies would be:\n\nStrategy 1: Navigate to the Books Forum\nSubstrategies: Access Forums, Select Alphabetical List, Choose Books Forum.\n\nStrategy 2: Sort Posts by Newest\nSubstrategies: Open Sort Options, Select New Sorting.\n\nStrategy 3: Upvote the Newest Post\nSubstrategies: Identify the Newest Post, Click Upvote Button.\n\nEach of these steps corresponds to the Playwright actions. Now, mapping each action to the Playwright idx.\n\nFor Strategy 1:\n\n- Access Forums: action 0 (link_Forums)\n- Select Alphabetical: action1 (link_Alphabetical)\n- Choose Books: action2 (link_books)\n\nStrategy 2:\n\n- Open Sort Options: action3 (clicking the \"Sort by: Hot\" label)\n- Select New: action4 (clicking the \"New\" link)\n\nStrategy3:\n\n- Identify the Newest Post: maybe part of the page after sorting, no action needed.\n- Click Upvote: action5.\n\nSo the substrategies and actions would be:\n\nStrategy 1: Navigate to the Books Forum\nSubstrategies:\n- Access Forums (action0)\n- Select Alphabetical List (action1)\n- Choose Books Forum (action2)\n\nEach of these substrategies has one action each.\n\nStrategy 2: Sort Posts by Newest\nSubstrategies:\n- Open Sort Options (action3)\n- Select New Sorting (action4)\n\nStrategy3: Upvote the Newest Post\nSubstrategies:\n- Locate and Upvote Newest Post (action5)\n\nNow, the example output uses strategy, substrategy, actions. Each substrategy can have multiple actions, but in this case, each substrategy is a single action.\n\nSo the JSON structure would have strategies with substrategies, each containing actions with description, playwright idx, and instruction.\n\nFor example, Strategy 1's substrategies:\n\nSubstrategy \"Access Forums\" has action: click Forums link (idx0, action_repr from Playwright data).\n\nSimilarly for others.\n\nNow, the Final Observations would note that after upvoting, the URL remains the same, indicating the upvote is handled via AJAX without a page reload. Also, the newest post is the first in the list when sorted by New.\n\nKey observations from Playwright trace: The upvote action (idx5) occurs on the /f/books/new page, confirming the correct sorting. The URL doesn't change after upvoting, suggesting an asynchronous request.\n\nPutting it all together in the required JSON format.\n</think>\n\n```json\n[\n {\n \"strategy\": \"Navigate to the Books Forum\",\n \"substrategies\": [\n {\n \"substrategy\": \"Access Forums\",\n \"actions\": [\n {\n \"description\": \"Click the 'Forums' link to navigate to the forums section.\",\n \"playwright_idx\": 0,\n \"playwright_instruction\": \"frame.clickget_by_role(\\\"link\\\", name=\\\"Forums\\\")\"\n }\n ]\n },\n {\n \"substrategy\": \"Select Alphabetical List\",\n \"actions\": [\n {\n \"description\": \"Click the 'Alphabetical' tab to list forums alphabetically.\",\n \"playwright_idx\": 1,\n \"playwright_instruction\": \"frame.clickget_by_role(\\\"link\\\", name=\\\"Alphabetical\\\")\"\n }\n ]\n },\n {\n \"substrategy\": \"Choose Books Forum\",\n \"actions\": [\n {\n \"description\": \"Click the 'books' forum link to enter the books subreddit.\",\n \"playwright_idx\": 2,\n \"playwright_instruction\": \"frame.clickget_by_role(\\\"link\\\", name=\\\"books\\\")\"\n }\n ]\n }\n ]\n },\n {\n \"strategy\": \"Sort Posts by Newest\",\n \"substrategies\": [\n {\n \"substrategy\": \"Open Sort Options\",\n \"actions\": [\n {\n \"description\": \"Click the 'Sort by: Hot' dropdown to open sorting options.\",\n \"playwright_idx\": 3,\n \"playwright_instruction\": \"frame.clickget_by_label(\\\"Sort by: Hot\\\")\"\n }\n ]\n },\n {\n \"substrategy\": \"Select New Sorting\",\n \"actions\": [\n {\n \"description\": \"Select the 'New' option to sort posts by most recent.\",\n \"playwright_idx\": 4,\n \"playwright_instruction\": \"frame.clickget_by_role(\\\"link\\\", name=\\\"New\\\", exact=True)\"\n }\n ]\n }\n ]\n },\n {\n \"strategy\": \"Upvote the Newest Post\",\n \"substrategies\": [\n {\n \"substrategy\": \"Locate and Upvote Newest Post\",\n \"actions\": [\n {\n \"description\": \"Click the 'Upvote' button on the first post in the sorted list (newest).\",\n \"playwright_idx\": 5,\n \"playwright_instruction\": \"frame.clicklocator(\\\"article\\\").filter(has_text=\\\"Adults reading to each other out loud? Submitted by BitterStatus9 t3_1281s7t 6 m\\\").get_by_title(\\\"Upvote\\\")\"\n }\n ]\n }\n ]\n }\n]\n```",
"final_output": [
{
"strategy": "Navigate to the Books Forum",
"substrategies": [
{
"substrategy": "Access Forums",
"actions": [
{
"description": "Click the 'Forums' link to navigate to the forums section.",
"playwright_idx": 0,
"playwright_instruction": "frame.clickget_by_role(\"link\", name=\"Forums\")"
}
]
},
{
"substrategy": "Select Alphabetical List",
"actions": [
{
"description": "Click the 'Alphabetical' tab to list forums alphabetically.",
"playwright_idx": 1,
"playwright_instruction": "frame.clickget_by_role(\"link\", name=\"Alphabetical\")"
}
]
},
{
"substrategy": "Choose Books Forum",
"actions": [
{
"description": "Click the 'books' forum link to enter the books subreddit.",
"playwright_idx": 2,
"playwright_instruction": "frame.clickget_by_role(\"link\", name=\"books\")"
}
]
}
]
},
{
"strategy": "Sort Posts by Newest",
"substrategies": [
{
"substrategy": "Open Sort Options",
"actions": [
{
"description": "Click the 'Sort by: Hot' dropdown to open sorting options.",
"playwright_idx": 3,
"playwright_instruction": "frame.clickget_by_label(\"Sort by: Hot\")"
}
]
},
{
"substrategy": "Select New Sorting",
"actions": [
{
"description": "Select the 'New' option to sort posts by most recent.",
"playwright_idx": 4,
"playwright_instruction": "frame.clickget_by_role(\"link\", name=\"New\", exact=True)"
}
]
}
]
},
{
"strategy": "Upvote the Newest Post",
"substrategies": [
{
"substrategy": "Locate and Upvote Newest Post",
"actions": [
{
"description": "Click the 'Upvote' button on the first post in the sorted list (newest).",
"playwright_idx": 5,
"playwright_instruction": "frame.clicklocator(\"article\").filter(has_text=\"Adults reading to each other out loud? Submitted by BitterStatus9 t3_1281s7t 6 m\").get_by_title(\"Upvote\")"
}
]
}
]
}
]
}